Every December, a few church basements in southern Wisconsin fill with steam, butter and the faint, unmistakable smell of lye-cured cod. Lutefisk has a reputation that walks into the room ahead of it. In Stoughton, a town shaped by Norwegian immigrants in the 1800s, that reputation is part of the fun, and the fish is only one of the Norwegian Christmas traditions that made the Atlantic crossing and stayed.
Not everything survived the trip intact. Some customs settled comfortably into Wisconsin church calendars, and at least one mostly faded away within a few generations. This is a field guide to Norwegian Christmas traditions in Stoughton: where they came from, where to find them now, and which ones you’ll have to imagine.
How Norway keeps Christmas Norwegian
In Norway, the main event is Christmas Eve, julaften. Church bells ring the holiday in at 5pm, a moment Norwegians call ringe julen inn, and dinner follows. What lands on the table depends on where your family is from. Pork rib roast is the standard in the east, pinnekjøtt (salted, dried and steamed lamb or mutton ribs) rules the west and north, and lutefisk and cod hold on in the south. The night before, December 23, is lille julaften, or Little Christmas Eve, when many families trim the tree.
Somewhere in the season there is rice porridge with a single almond hidden in the pot. Whoever finds it usually wins a marzipan pig. And no respectable Norwegian kitchen gets through the holidays without baking an assortment of Christmas cookies, traditionally seven kinds.
The families who arrived in Dane County carried versions of all of this with them, along with trunks, hymnals and very strong opinions about coffee. If you want the longer story of who they were and why they came, start with the history of Norwegian settlement in Stoughton.
Lutefisk, explained: a Norwegian Christmas staple in Wisconsin
Lutefisk starts as dried cod or whitefish. It is soaked in a lye solution until it swells, then rinsed in fresh water for days to wash the lye back out. Cooked, it turns pale and translucent, with a texture somewhere between delicate fish and a very confident custard. It is served with melted butter, and in Wisconsin, a great deal of it.
The dish was a practical answer to a long winter and a long ocean voyage. Joan Scholz, a longtime volunteer at a church lutefisk supper in DeForest, put it plainly to Wisconsin Life: “It was a way for immigrants to bring their native food here.” Nobody claims everyone loves it. That’s what the meatballs are for.
The church lutefisk supper has become its own Norwegian Christmas tradition in Wisconsin. Every fall and winter, congregations across the Upper Midwest set long tables, roll out the lefse and feed whoever shows up, often with the same volunteers in the kitchen year after year. The DeForest crew Wisconsin Life visited had people who’d been helping since the 1970s.
Where to find a lutefisk dinner near Stoughton
The big one nearby is the annual Lutefisk and Meatball Dinner at Christ Lutheran Church in DeForest, about 40 minutes north of Stoughton. The congregation dates to 1847, and for the 2026 dinner on Saturday, November 14, it expects around 1,400 people, with seatings every hour from 11am to 5pm. The menu is lutefisk, homemade meatballs, potato lefse, rutabagas, mashed potatoes and gravy, coleslaw, cranberries and pie: $28 for adults and $13 for children ages 4 to 12. Reservations for 2026 seatings closed on November 3, but carryout can be ordered on the day of the event. Call the office at 608-846-4718 for more information or to learn about next year’s event.
The church also sells lutefisk by the pound and herring by the pail for cooking at home.
Most church lutefisk dinners in southern Wisconsin fall between late October and early December, and many close reservations weeks ahead. The Sons of Norway District 5 events calendar keeps the best running list. If you’d rather take Norwegian food home, Stoughton’s Sons of Norway lodge holds its Fall Bake Sale on Saturday, November 21, 2026, from 8am to 2pm, selling lefse, rømmegrøt and frozen meatballs while they last. There are no early sales, so plan to be there at 8.
Lefse, krumkake and the Christmas cookie tin
Lefse is the friendlier ambassador. It’s a soft potato flatbread, rolled thin and cooked on a griddle, and at Christmas it’s buttered, sprinkled with sugar, rolled up and eaten faster than anyone will admit. Krumkake are thin cookies pressed in a patterned iron and rolled into cones while still hot. Rosettes are fried on a decorative iron and dusted with powdered sugar. Fattigmann, the “poor man’s” cookie, is a fried, cardamom-scented twist with a name that undersells it.
Downtown, Fosdal Home Bakery at 243 E. Main St. is best known for its donuts, but as noted by The Norwegian American, krumkake, fattigmann and rosettes can be found in its cases alongside cookies iced in Norwegian flag colors. Stop in early on a December Saturday to taste how Fosdal is keeping Stoughton’s Norwegian Christmas traditions alive in the sweetest way.
Julebukking: the Norwegian Christmas tradition that mostly didn’t make it
Julebukking is the one people ask about, usually after hearing a grandparent mention it. During the Christmas season, Norway neighbors would dress in disguises, sometimes with a goat mask in honor of the julebukk or Yule goat, and go door to door. The hosts had to guess who was under the costume, and once they did, the visitors were rewarded with treats and, very often, a drink. One writer has described it as a Norwegian Halloween party in December, which is about right.
It faded on both sides of the Atlantic. In a 2021 piece for The Norwegian American, a writer recalled his cousin in Norway explaining why it died out there: visiting ten or twelve houses with a drink at each simply became too much. In Wisconsin, where deer-hunting season coincides with the holidays, showing up unannounced at night in a horned mask seemed ill-advised, so the custom died off quickly. Now it sounds more like the premise of an A24 movie than a Norwegian Christmas tradition that carries on in Stoughton.
So while you probably won’t get masked julebukkers at your door these days, the goat itself hung on. In Norway, the straw julebukk is still a common Christmas ornament, a small reminder of a custom that once gave the whole season a sense of mischief.
What Stoughton still keeps in terms of Norwegian Christmas
Stoughton’s Victorian Holiday Weekend runs Friday, December 4 through Sunday, December 6, 2026. The weekend brings a holiday light show at Rotary Park, the Stoughton High School Madrigal Singers caroling in period costume, pictures with Santa and a fire truck parade down Main Street, and the organizers invite everyone to wear their heritage folk dress downtown, bunad very much included. Our guide to Stoughton holiday events has the full weekend schedule plus additional December holiday concerts.
Mandt Lodge, Stoughton’s Sons of Norway lodge on South Page Street, marked its 100th anniversary with an open house on November 1, 2026. It’s where lefse and lutefisk get made for the town’s Norwegian celebrations, and it anchored the Sons of Norway District 5 convention when it came to Stoughton in August 2026 (more on that in our post about the 2026 Sons of Norway convention in Stoughton).
The lodge keeps December busy, too. On Thursday, December 10, 2026, at 7pm, the Edvard Grieg Chorus, a Norwegian men’s chorus founded in Madison in 1925, gives a Christmas concert at Mandt Lodge and leads a sing-along of carols in Norwegian and English. There’s a free-will offering for the chorus, and refreshments afterward. On Saturday, December 12, from 8:30 to 11:30am, the lodge’s Norwegian Family Christmas morning brings a lefse, donut and bake sale, children’s crafts, a kids-only shop with $1 gifts for the family, and free photos with Santa. The lodge asks visitors to bring something for the Stoughton Food Pantry.
About 40 minutes away in Mount Horeb, Vennelag Lodge holds its Juletrefest on Sunday, December 6, 2026, at 4:30pm at the Mount Horeb Community Center. A juletrefest is a Christmas-tree party, and its centerpiece is the old Norwegian custom of joining hands and circling the tree while everyone sings. Expect a Norwegian meatball dinner, Christmas carols and Norwegian songs, and plenty of sweaters and bunads. It’s a lodge celebration, so check with Vennelag Lodge about tickets before you go.
For context before or after dinner, spend an hour at Livsreise, the Norwegian heritage center on Main Street. Admission is free, and its exhibits walk you through why so many Norwegians left home and what it took to get here. Our guide to visiting the Livsreise Norwegian Heritage Center has hours and highlights.
Then there is the house itself. Jens Naeset built the home on East Washington Street in 1878, and his wife, Gertrude, became known for taking in newly arrived Norwegian families, giving them a bed and a hot meal while they found their footing. You can read more about the Naeset family and the house’s history. The habit of welcoming people in from the cold at this address is a good deal older than the inn.
Plan a Norwegian Christmas weekend in Stoughton
The best way to do Norwegian Christmas in Stoughton is slowly: a morning at Livsreise, a bakery bag of krumkake, a lutefisk dinner if your nerve holds, and the lights downtown after dark. Then somewhere warm to end the night. The Lighthouse, our room inspired by the Norwegian immigrants’ Atlantic crossing, looks out on the Opera House clock tower and has a spa tub that makes short work of a cold walk home.
Pick your December weekend, check the lutefisk schedule, and book your stay at The Goose Crown Inn.